Comparative Study Investigates Teacher Workload and Wellbeing in Finland and SA

University of KwaZulu-Natal (UKZN) graduate Mr Sabelo Mhlongo earned a Master of Education in Teacher Development through research focused on teacher workload and wellbeing.

Mhlongo’s research was deeply personal, influenced by his mentor/teacher’s workload, Ms Magwaza, who passionately taught Economics to Grades 10, 11 and 12, as well as five Grade 8 Economic and Management Sciences classes.

Mhlongo’s study examines secondary school teachers’ workload and its implications for teacher wellbeing and teaching practices, with a comparative focus on South Africa and Finland. Rather than viewing workload simply in terms of the number of hours teachers work or the number of tasks they complete, the study examines it as a complex and multidimensional phenomenon.

“It considers various dimensions of workload, including teaching responsibilities, lesson preparation, assessment and marking, administrative duties, emotional and relational demands, class sizes, curriculum requirements, professional expectations and the broader institutional and systemic pressures that influence teachers’ everyday experiences,” explained Mhlongo.

The study compares South Africa and Finland because the two education systems operate within significantly different structural, policy, resource and organisational contexts. This comparison provides an opportunity to understand how different approaches to teacher workload and professional support may shape teachers’ experiences.

In particular, the research seeks to understand how teacher workload is defined, structured, experienced and managed in both education systems, and how these factors influence teachers’ wellbeing, motivation, professional engagement and ability to carry out their teaching responsibilities effectively.

One of the study’s significant findings is that teacher workload extends beyond the number of hours worked to include the intensity and broader conditions of teachers’ professional responsibilities.

The comparative findings revealed an important difference between South Africa and Finland. In South Africa, high workload volumes, large classes, extensive administrative responsibilities, reporting requirements and limited time for lesson preparation contribute to stress, fatigue and reduced job satisfaction, while limiting teachers’ ability to provide individualised attention and implement effective teaching practices.

In contrast, Finnish teachers may also experience demanding and emotionally complex work, but stronger professional autonomy, collaborative school cultures, structured planning time, manageable class sizes and supportive policy frameworks appear to buffer some of the negative effects of workload.

Mhlongo believes his research can benefit society by contributing to a better understanding of how teacher workload affects teacher wellbeing and the quality of teaching. It could also assist policymakers, school leaders and education stakeholders in developing more sustainable working conditions for teachers.

“Ultimately, by improving the conditions under which teachers work, the findings can contribute to healthier and more motivated teachers, better teaching practices, improved learner support and potentially better educational outcomes,” he said.

Supervisor, Professor Anja Philipp commends Mhlongo for his excellent reflections and his outstanding ability to quickly process new information and provide deep insights into new topics. He said: “Besides his outstanding academic and intellectual abilities, Sabelo also struck me as particularly thoughtful and responsible. He takes on leadership opportunities and mentors fellow students.”

Mhlongo aims to continue contributing to the field of education through research.

Words: Sinoyolo Mahlasela

Photograph: Tisetso Nhlapo

Latest

I-Reclaiming UQOBO Ibheke Ukuxhumana Phakathi Kobugugu Nempilo

Isifundo Sokuqala Besigxile Kwezempilo Ezinobuqotho

Related

Umfundi Wezobudokotela Uhlabene Emncintiswaneni Wocwaningo LweFiziyoloji

Iqembu le-Goalball Lase-UKZN Libuye neSiliva Emqhudelwaneni wase-Clermont