Can Rehabilitation Break the Cycle of Crime? Critical PhD Investigates

The impact of incarceration was visible in Dr Nozibusiso Nkosi’s community long before it became the subject of her doctoral research.

Growing up in KwaMashu, Nkosi recalls that there were many households led by women because fathers, uncles and brothers were incarcerated. The experience prompted questions that would eventually shape her academic journey: what drives people back into crime, and can rehabilitation genuinely break the cycle of reoffending?

Supervised by Professor Shanta Balgobind Singh, Nkosi’s PhD research, ‘An Analysis of the Effectiveness of Rehabilitation Programmes on Repeat Offending in Three Correctional Centres in KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa’, examined whether rehabilitation programmes offered by the Department of Correctional Services (DCS) were achieving their intended purpose.

Nkosi’s interest was strengthened by her experience as a former Vice Chairperson of the Correctional Supervision and Parole Board and an Independent Correctional Centre Visitor for the Judicial Inspectorate for Correctional Services. She regularly encountered offenders who were released and later returned after committing new offences.

“I kept asking myself whether rehabilitation programmes were really working, and what could be learned from other countries,” she said.

Her research took her into three correctional centres, where she found conditions that made rehabilitation difficult. Overcrowding, limited resources, security concerns and gang activity created an environment in which meaningful rehabilitation was difficult to achieve.

One conversation with offenders particularly stayed with her. They told her that rehabilitation programmes were not necessarily changing their behaviour, but that they participated because they wanted to qualify for parole.

The finding raised a fundamental concern for Nkosi: participation cannot be the same as rehabilitation.

She argues that rehabilitation needs to move beyond a blanket approach and consider individual risks and circumstances. Vocational training, for example, could give offenders with little education or work experience practical skills to support themselves after release. She also recommends that rehabilitation assessments and interventions begin soon after admission, before individuals become further entrenched in gangs and criminal networks.

Yet her research did not leave her without hope. She encountered offenders who wanted to change, pursued further studies and acquired skills where opportunities were available. Some even worked inside correctional centres for sums of money. Nkosi observed that the work represented far more than financial reward: it offered dignity and purpose and reflected a determination to change.

Her central recommendation is that DCS should evaluate whether rehabilitation programmes work, rather than simply whether they exist or whether offenders have attended them.

A programme that repeatedly produces the same outcomes, she concludes, risks becoming a process rather than a pathway to change.

A lecturer at the University of Limpopo, Nkosi intends to continue exploring evidence-based approaches to rehabilitation in South Africa, with the goal of helping to break the cycle of reoffending and contributing to safer communities.

Words: Rakshika Sibran

Photograph: Tisetso Nhlapo

Latest

I-Reclaiming UQOBO Ibheke Ukuxhumana Phakathi Kobugugu Nempilo

Isifundo Sokuqala Besigxile Kwezempilo Ezinobuqotho

Related

Umfundi Wezobudokotela Uhlabene Emncintiswaneni Wocwaningo LweFiziyoloji

Iqembu le-Goalball Lase-UKZN Libuye neSiliva Emqhudelwaneni wase-Clermont